Paycom (PAYC) Q3 2026 10-Q: Buyback at $128.56 and the CEO's 1.09M-Share Sale Plan
Listen to this report
The Hook
Paycom Software $PAYC spent the first half of 2026 buying its own stock with borrowed money: 10,960,280 shares in nine months at an average cost of $128.56, about 20% of the 54.8M shares it had outstanding on December 31. At the November 20 close of $241.64 (stockanalysis.com), those shares are worth about $2.65B against a cost of about $1.41B. The coverage of the third quarter called the 20% EPS beat "financial engineering" built on buybacks and debt (24/7 Wall St., November 4). The quarter's own 10-Q shows two things that framing leaves out. As the price climbed, the company stopped buying: no open-market shares in July or August, and 5,785 in September at $215.02. And in Item 5 it discloses that an entity of founder and CEO Chad Richison adopted a trading plan on September 1 to sell up to 1,090,000 shares between December 1, 2026 and June 1, 2027. The company bought at $128; its founder has queued a sale at whatever the plan's price limits allow, from a stock that now trades near twice that.
Company Snapshot
Paycom sells cloud payroll and human capital management software from a single database, priced largely per employee of each client, to organizations from 50 to over 10,000 employees. It reports one segment and also earns interest on the payroll funds it holds for clients. This brief reads the Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026 (filed November 5, accession 0001193125-26-449828), with the two earlier 2026 10-Qs for the quarter-by-quarter buyback, the FY2025 10-K, the November 4 earnings 8-K, and the filings made since.
The Financial Story
The quarter itself was a cost story, and the market has it. Revenue rose 10.2% to $543.8M, recurring and other revenue 11.3% to $519.3M, while interest on client funds fell to $24.5M from $26.8M. Operating income rose 73.9% to $195.8M, a 36.0% operating margin against 22.8% a year earlier. Almost all of it came from spending less: total research and development cost, expensed plus capitalized, fell 52% to $55.9M from $117.6M; sales and marketing fell $17.7M, $15.6M of it advertising; and stock-based compensation fell to $20.3M from $31.1M. The 10-Q cites lower headcount in cost of revenues, sales and marketing, and R&D. The 10-K counted 5,770 employees at the end of 2025.
| Q3 (three months to Sept 30) | 2026 | 2025 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | $543.8M | $493.3M | 10.2% |
| Operating income | $195.8M | $112.6M | 73.9% |
| Interest expense | $11.7M | $1.1M | |
| Other income, net | $1.2M | $41.3M | |
| Net income | $133.2M | $110.7M | 20.3% |
| Diluted shares | 44.526M | 56.427M | -21.1% |
| Diluted EPS | $2.99 | $1.96 | 52.6% |
Net income rose 20%; EPS rose 53%. The gap is the share count. Pretax income grew only 21.3% because last year's quarter carried $41.3M of other income, $35.6M of it a one-time gain on amending the Oklahoma City arena naming rights agreement, and because the revolver now costs interest. Diluted shares fell 21.1%, and that is the whole distance between a 20.3% rise in net income and a 52.6% rise in diluted EPS.
How the shares were bought, quarter by quarter. The buyback was not a steady program. It was a burst at the low and a stop on the way up, funded by a $2.125B secured revolver drawn for the first time.
| 2026 | Shares repurchased | Average cost | Treasury cost | Revolver |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 | 8,375,443 | $126.61 | $1,070.8M | +$675.0M |
| Q2 | 2,570,072 | about $134.57 | $349.0M | +$225.0M |
| Q3 | 14,765 | 8,980 withheld for tax at $173.82; 5,785 at $215.02 | $2.8M | -$150.0M |
| Nine months | 10,960,280 | $128.56 | $1,422.6M | $750.0M outstanding |
Q2 shares and average cost are derived from the Q1 and six-month figures each 10-Q reports. The nine months' cash outlay for repurchases was $1,390.9M. The board raised the authorization to $2.0B on May 4, and $1,652.7M of it was still unused on September 30.
What the borrowing costs, and what it bought. Interest expense was $26.2M for nine months against $2.7M a year earlier, an extra $23.5M. Against that, dividends paid fell $11.9M to $52.2M, which the 10-Q attributes to fewer shares outstanding, and the shares themselves are up about 88% from their average cost. The revolver bears SOFR plus 1.25% to 2.00%, matures April 23, 2031, and caps leverage at 3.5 times; buybacks beyond $50M a year need pro forma leverage under 3.0 times. With $750.0M drawn and $193.9M of cash, the cap is far away. The debt is not the risk the coverage made it sound.
Cash flow is flattered by a capex trough. Operating cash flow was $613.9M for nine months and purchases of property and equipment $77.4M, down from $197.4M, leaving $536.5M. That capex is about half of the $151.9M of depreciation and amortization over the same months, and management guided capex near 6% of revenue (call transcript via TradingKey, November 5). The capitalized share of R&D fell 60% in Q3 to $17.4M. Spending below depreciation for a while is cheap; spending below it for years is a decision about the product.
Valuation: what it's worth as a normal business
At $241.64 and the 45,034,789 shares on the 10-Q cover (October 27), Paycom's market value is about $10.88B; adding the $750.0M revolver and netting $193.9M of cash gives an enterprise value of about $11.44B. On trailing figures built from the 10-K and the two nine-month periods, the market value is about 5.0 times revenue of $2,191.1M and 21.3 times net income of $510.1M, the enterprise value is 12.3 times EBITDA of $932.9M (operating income plus depreciation, before adding back stock compensation), and free cash flow of $659.1M is a 6.1% yield on the market value. Stockanalysis.com (November 20) lists a Hold consensus from 21 analysts with an average target of $271.00 and a forward P/E of 16.3.
| Peer (stockanalysis.com, Nov 20 close, its own EBITDA definition) | Forward P/E | EV/EBITDA | FCF yield |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paycom (PAYC) | 16.3 | 13.6 | 6.2% |
| Paylocity (PCTY) | 18.4 | 20.6 | 5.5% |
| Paychex (PAYX) | 18.6 | 14.2 | 5.0% |
| ADP (ADP) | 23.9 | 18.5 | 4.4% |
A scenario DCF at the house 9% discount rate, five explicit years, then a terminal value, with $556.1M of net debt subtracted and 45.03M shares:
| Case | Starting FCF | FCF growth, years 1-5 | Terminal growth | Implied value per share |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bear | $620M (capex raised to the depreciation run rate) | 0% | 2% | about $172 |
| Base | $680M | 6% | 3% | about $283 |
| Bull | $720M | 10% | 3% | about $357 |
The bear case cuts the terminal rate to 2% because per-employee pricing is exposed if clients automate jobs away, which is exactly how Paycom cut its own costs this year. Applying the Paychex multiple of 14.2 times to the $932.9M of trailing EBITDA gives about $282 a share; the ADP multiple of 18.5 times gives about $371. Today's price is what the base DCF returns if free cash flow grows about 2.5% a year for five years: the market is paying for a company that grows slower than the 8% revenue guide. That is a range of implied values under stated assumptions, not a price target and not investment advice. The company's own behavior marks the range more plainly than a model does: it bought heavily below $135, bought almost nothing in the third quarter as the price climbed, with $1.65B of authorization unused, and its founder's plan to sell begins in December with the stock near $240.
Risks
The full-year guide in the November 4 8-K, revenue of $2.213B to $2.218B, implies fourth-quarter revenue of $566.2M to $571.2M, growth of 4.0% to 4.9% over the $544.3M of the fourth quarter of 2025, against 10.2% in the third. The margin came from cutting R&D by half and capex below depreciation, and both can be reversed by the need to keep up. Revenue is billed partly per client employee, and the 10-Q says the business is sensitive to the labor market; automation that shrinks client payrolls shrinks the meter. Interest on client funds fell 8.6% in Q3 as rates fell. The quarter also carried an $11.0M legal settlement charge in general and administrative expense, with no detail given. On the insider side, the Richison plan carries price restrictions the filing does not disclose, and since the 10-Q the CFO sold 2,105 shares at $251.26 (November 17) and the COO 4,645 at about $248.85 (November 13), per their Forms 4; all small against holdings.
The Bottom Line
Paycom is a 10% grower that cut its way to a 36% operating margin and spent $1.41B retiring a fifth of its stock at $128.56. That part worked: the shares are worth about $2.65B today. The part the coverage missed is what happened after. The buying stopped in the third quarter as the price climbed, the authorization sits mostly unused, and the founder, who owns 13.1% of the company, has a plan to sell up to 1,090,000 shares starting December 1. Neither is a verdict on the business, and a diversification plan with price limits is ordinary. But the two parties who know Paycom best, its board allocating capital and its founder, are both telling you which side of $200 they prefer to be on. Watch the fourth quarter's growth against the 4% to 5% the guide implies, any repurchases in the next 10-Q, and the Forms 4 that the Richison plan will produce from December.
Nobody wrote these numbers by hand. The buyback's average cost, the quarter-by-quarter split and the founder's sale plan all came out of the filings themselves, and the same pipeline reads any of the companies that file with the SEC, or a private company that reports in the same format.
Every figure about Paycom in this brief comes from its SEC filings (Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026, the Q1 and Q2 2026 10-Qs, the FY2025 10-K, the November 4 8-K, Schedule 13D/A amendment 21 and Forms 4), read and verified through RoboSystems. Prices, consensus and peer multiples are attributed and dated where they appear.
Ask the filing yourself
Every figure in this report came from Paycom Software, Inc.'s SEC filings in the RoboSystems SEC Shared Repository. Connect it to Claude or ChatGPT and ask your own questions, starting with this one:
What average price did Paycom pay for the shares it repurchased in the first nine months of 2026, and how many shares did it buy?