Elastic (ESTC) Q2 FY2027 10-Q: The 99% Tax Rate Behind the P/E
Listen to this report
The Hook
Elastic $ESTC made $28.2M of pre-tax income in the quarter to October 31, 2026, and was charged $28.0M of income tax on it. Net income was $171 thousand, an effective tax rate the 10-Q puts at 99%. One widely read recap, SiliconANGLE's on November 19, reported that net income as $171 million. The filing says thousand.
SiliconANGLE's November 19 report tied the stock's slide to third-quarter guidance below forecasts. The more useful number is the one underneath every quoted P/E: the 18.7x trailing multiple stockanalysis.com showed on November 20 rests on a $370.1M tax benefit booked in fiscal 2026, when Elastic released valuation allowances on its deferred tax assets. Over the last four quarters Elastic earned about $7.3M before tax and reported $427.1M after it. The tax line made last year's profit, and it is now taking this year's.
Company Snapshot
Elastic N.V. is a Netherlands-incorporated software company built on Elasticsearch, selling search, observability and security, mostly as subscriptions and increasingly as Elastic Cloud. It reports one operating segment. This brief reads its 10-Q for the second quarter of fiscal 2027, the three months ended October 31, 2026, filed November 20, 2026, with the fiscal 2026 10-K (filed June 8, 2026) for the tax history.
The Financial Story
The top line is healthy, and the mix inside it is the real story. Revenue rose 17.1% to $495.9M. Annual Elastic Cloud, the committed contracts, grew 29.7% to $203.4M and is now 41% of revenue, up from 37%. Monthly Elastic Cloud, the pay-as-you-go business, grew 2.9% to $50.2M and was flat on the prior quarter. Other subscription, mostly self-managed, grew 10.1%. Elastic is growing where customers sign contracts and standing still where they swipe a card.
| Revenue line, Q2 FY27 | Q2 FY27 | Q2 FY26 | Growth |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annual Elastic Cloud | $203.4M | $156.9M | 29.7% |
| Monthly Elastic Cloud | $50.2M | $48.8M | 2.9% |
| Other subscription | $211.5M | $192.0M | 10.1% |
| Services | $30.8M | $25.8M | 19.3% |
| Total revenue | $495.9M | $423.5M | 17.1% |
Operations turned the corner on a GAAP basis. Gross margin held at 76.0%. Operating income was $22.1M, a 4.4% margin, against an $8.2M operating loss a year earlier, even after $2.4M of restructuring charges (the plan announced June 24, 2026 to cut about 7% of the workforce has cost $22.3M in the half). Stock-based compensation was $78.2M in the quarter, 15.8% of revenue, which is most of the gap between this GAAP margin and the company's non-GAAP one. Add $12.5M of other income, mostly interest, less $6.4M of interest on the $575M of 4.125% notes due 2029, and pre-tax income was $28.2M.
Then the tax line takes it all, and that is the lead. In fiscal 2026 Elastic decided its Dutch, UK and California deferred tax assets were now more likely than not to be used, and released $434.9M of valuation allowances ($390.5M of it in the Netherlands). That produced a $370.1M tax benefit on a $2.3M pre-tax loss, and $367.8M of net income. The 10-K tied the Dutch and California releases to "a committed tax planning action in fiscal 2027". The bill for that accounting arrives now: with $548.6M of deferred tax assets on the balance sheet, every dollar of profit is taxed at book rates, and non-deductible stock compensation and the US base-erosion tax push the rate far above statutory. The first quarter shows the asymmetry at its starkest: a $17.3M pre-tax loss earned a tax benefit of just $0.5M.
| Tax line | Pre-tax income | Tax charged | Net income |
|---|---|---|---|
| FY2026 | -$2.3M | -$370.1M (benefit) | $367.8M |
| Q1 FY27 | -$17.3M | -$0.5M (benefit) | -$16.7M |
| Q2 FY27 | $28.2M | $28.0M | $0.2M |
| Last four quarters | $7.3M | -$419.8M (benefit) | $427.1M |
Charged is not paid, and the cash says so. Of the $27.5M of tax charged in the first half, $18.1M was deferred, a drawdown of the asset, not cash. Cash out the door for income taxes in the half was $12.9M (the filing's cash-paid line), against $28.0M for all of fiscal 2026. The cash business is doing better than the GAAP line suggests: operating cash flow was $175.8M in the half, up 33.7% from $131.4M, and capital spending was under $1M. Elastic ended October with $1,422.6M of cash and marketable securities against the $575M of notes.
The other filing detail worth having is the buyback's timing. Elastic bought shares cheaply in the summer and dearly in the autumn. It repurchased 804,601 shares at $49.71 in the first quarter and 640,742 at $86.31 in the second, and had $64.7M of authorization left at October 31 and about $45.0M by November 16, so roughly $19.7M more went out in the first half of November. The board added a new $500M program on November 17. The stock closed at $74.79 on November 20, per stockanalysis.com.
| Quarter | Shares repurchased | Average price | Amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q2 FY26 | 1,351,652 | $84.45 | $114.1M |
| Q1 FY27 | 804,601 | $49.71 | $40.0M |
| Q2 FY27 | 640,742 | $86.31 | $55.3M |
Valuation: what it's worth as a normal business
Where it trades. At $74.79 (stockanalysis.com, November 20 close) and the 105,699,302 shares on the 10-Q cover, Elastic's market value is about $7.9B. Net of $1,422.6M of cash and securities and $575M of notes, enterprise value is about $7.06B: 3.8x trailing revenue of $1,874.6M and 19.0x trailing operating cash flow of $371.2M. A trailing P/E of 18.5x on the filing's numbers (18.7x on stockanalysis.com on November 20) is a tax artifact; the stock trades on cash flow, not earnings. Per stockanalysis.com on November 20, the 30 analysts covering it rate it a Buy with an average target of $103.74, and peers trade at higher sales multiples: Dynatrace 5.4x, MongoDB 7.4x and Datadog 12.4x enterprise value to sales.
Scenario DCF. Five years of free cash flow from trailing revenue, the house 9% discount rate and 3% terminal growth, $847.6M of net cash, and 108.46M diluted shares. Free cash flow here treats stock compensation as non-cash, as the company's own adjusted figure does; at 15.7% of first-half revenue it is a real cost, partly offset by buybacks, and the bear case should be read with that in mind.
| Case | Revenue growth, years 1-5 | FCF margin | Implied value per share |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bear | 10% falling to 5% | 18% | about $72 |
| Base | 14% falling to 10% | 21% | about $99 |
| Bull | 16% falling to 13% | 24% | about $125 |
Re-rating and what the price implies. At the 5.4x trailing sales stockanalysis.com showed for Dynatrace on November 20, Elastic would be worth about $101 a share; at MongoDB's 7.4x on the same source and date, about $136. Run backwards, the $74.79 November 20 close (stockanalysis.com) is roughly what the model returns for 5% annual revenue growth over five years at a 21% margin, against 17% in the latest quarter and the roughly 13% the company guided for the next one in the earnings release filed with its November 19 8-K. Implied value under stated assumptions, not a price target and not investment advice.
Risks
The committed-cloud engine is strong but the pay-as-you-go cloud is flat. One channel partner still accounts for 10% of revenue, down from 11% in fiscal 2026 and 12% in fiscal 2025. The tax line now cuts the other way: with the valuation allowance gone, GAAP earnings will carry a high book rate for as long as stock compensation stays this large, and the 10-Q does not update the "committed tax planning action" that supported the release. The restructuring and an announced deal for HoneyHive (per Elastic's blog on November 19, 2026, not yet in a filing) compete for management attention while the company guides growth lower.
The Bottom Line
Elastic is a 17%-growth software company with a strengthening committed-contract base and good cash generation, wearing an income statement that the tax line distorts in both directions: a $370.1M benefit that inflated last year and a 99% rate that erased this quarter. Watch three things: whether Monthly Cloud moves off flat, the effective tax rate on a full year of profit, and the prices the company gets on shares under the new $500M program. Read the cash flow, not the P/E.
Nobody wrote this from a press release. The 99% figure and the $370.1M benefit behind it came straight out of Elastic's SEC filings, its 10-Q and 10-K, and the same reading works on any of the thousands of companies that file with the SEC.
Every figure about Elastic comes from its SEC filings, read through RoboSystems. Market prices, consensus and peer multiples are attributed in the text.
Ask the filing yourself
Every figure in this report came from Elastic N.V.'s SEC filings in the RoboSystems SEC Shared Repository. Connect it to Claude or ChatGPT and ask your own questions, starting with this one:
What was Elastic's effective tax rate in the quarter ended October 31, 2026, and how does it compare with the tax benefit it booked in fiscal 2026?